Hashtag: They Always Have It
I just returned from a weekend poker trip to New Orleans. There were eight guys on this trip, one of whom – for purposes of this blog I’ll refer to him as “Tony” – was celebrating a birthday during the weekend.
We stayed in some fancy digs in the French Quarter, and played a lot of poker at Harrah’s New Orleans casino. On Saturday, there were a number of interesting hands, all at blinds of $1/3. Because this poker room allows players to buy-in up to the largest stack on the table, and also lets players straddle $6 from any position, the game plays larger than most $1/3 games, and much larger than most $1/2 games. Let’s get started.
Hand #1 – Nut Flush on a Paired Board
This was early in my day, so I didn’t have much in the way of player-specific reads. I have Kd Js on the button, and raise to $15 over a single limper. I started the hand with approx. $300 and the BB is the main villain and has me covered. The SB folds, but BB raises to $30. He could simply be putting me on a wide range trying to leverage my position on the button, and trying to re-steal, but his raise is too small if his goal is to make me fold. He is a middle aged white guy (like me!) making a barely minimum raise, so I need to give him credit for a strong or very strong hand. Everyone else folds, and I call. Heads up, in position, I’m willing to call $15 more with $52 already in the pot.
Flop ($67): Ad Jd 2d. All diamonds. He checks. I have the King of diamonds for a nut flush draw, and middle pair. While I could bet here as a semi-bluff, I actually have some showdown value and decide to take the free card instead. I’m not sure he will fold any Ace to a bet. I check.
Turn ($67): 2c. This card pairs the board but doesn’t otherwise change anything. He checks again. Does have have KK or QQ and hoping to get to a cheap showdown? In that case, perhaps I should make at least one steal attempt, but I’m not sure he would fold, especially if he has Qd Qx. Free cards are good, right? So I check again.
River: ($67) 8d. Awesome. This completes my nut flush. I’m anticipating another check when he fires out a bet of $45. I should have the best hand here, and might get a crying call if he has Ax Qd or Qd Qx. There really isn’t much else in his pre-flop 3-betting range that can make a weaker flush here, and he wouldn’t call me without either that or better. The Ad and Jd are on the board, and I have the Kd. Could he be as weak as Td Tc? I can’t imagine anything else will call a raise. If he comes back over the top of my raise, however, I need to be concerned about AA or JJ, although I would have expected either one of these to make a small be on the turn, for value, since he would have turned a full house and would want to continue building the pot.
I raise to $110. With very little hesitation, he declares that he’s all-in. Dammit! Now I pissed at myself for raising instead of just calling, although I can hear the voices of those who advocate bet/folding and raise/folding for value as superior long-term value strategies over calling whenever you have a big, but non-nut hand. I also here the voice of one of my favorite poker podcasters saying “hashtag: they always have it” (#theyalwayshaveit).
While trying to get emotionally unattached from my nut flush and decide if I’m a bad enough player to donate the rest of my chips, I replay the hand, try to recall any observations about this specific player and ponder his body language when he went all-in and the meaning of his very small pre-flop 3-bet. He seemed confident, not the least bit afraid of the fact that he cannot have the Kd. Yes, he has to have pocket aces here.
I fold, and in an act of pure kindness that I’ll exploit if given the chance, he flashes his AA for the entire table to see.
In hindsight, I think raising was a mistake on that river, as there were too few hands that would call a raise, and his pre-flop action certainly suggested AA as part of his range, with a small raise begging to be called.
Hand #2 – Does Small Turn Bet Signal Weakness?
After Hand #1, I add another $200 to my stack. Shortly after that, I am dealt Kh Jd in middle position, and two players limp in front of me. What is it with “jack-king-off” and me this weekend? I felted a woman (felted her, not felt her!) for a nearly $400 pot with this holding late the previous night, and here it is again in both Hand #1 and #2. This time, I raise to $18 and get called by the button and one of the limpers. I started this hand with $326 and the main villain on the button has me easily covered.
Flop ($61): Tc 9s 7c. This is an interesting flop, very drawy, giving me a double gutshot straight draw in addition to two over cards, while also hitting a lot of pre-flop calling ranges for flush draws, flopped straights or straight draws, combo draws, sets and more. The first guy checks. I want to retain the initiative, and bet $35 as a semi-bluff. Hopefully they missed this flop badly and will fold. Or the button will fold and I’ll have position on the other guy. The button does not cooperate, instead raising to $85, and the other guy folds leaving us heads up, with me being out-of-position
I don’t have any reads or tells on this player, as he is new at this table, a white male who appears to be in his mid-to-late 30’s. Since he called a raise pre-flop on the button, his range can be pretty wide but would exclude 3-betting hands like AA, KK or QQ. For now, I’ll give him credit for possibly raising with a flush or straight draw, combo draws, and strong made hands of top pair / top kicker or better. This range is JJ-77, Ac 2c+, Kc Jc+, Qc Jc, JT, J8s, T9, T7s, 98, 97s, 87, 86s, ATo.
The overall player pool in this poker room is very loose pre-flop. In position, a large portion will call with virtually any connecting cards (like JT, T9, 98 or 87) or suited 1- and 2-gappers (like J8, T8, 97 or 86).
This range includes 139 different combinations of two cards, more than 10% of all possible combinations. Even without a pair, I have 32.7% equity against his range. With $180 already in the pot and it costing me $50 more to call, I only need 21.7% equity to call even if I’m only assured of seeing one card. If it’s a blank and he fires out a large turn bet, I might have to bail out. I call.
Turn ($230): Ks. Now I have top pair, plus the double gutshot draw, and a second flush draw is now also a possibility.
I check and the button bets $50, less than 1/4 of the pot. This is a strangely small bet. With so many draws possible, I would expect a much larger bet from his stronger made hands – flopped straights or sets – as there would be a lot of hands I could have that would call again and he should be protecting against the draws. If he were semi-bluffing with a flush draw, he should be betting much more here, or else just check back and take a free card. My range is narrower than his, as I was the pre-flop raiser and less likely to be raising with the weaker connectors and gappers that he may have called with favorable position.
Against his full range, my equity is now 60.5%. I’m beating hands like T8, 98, 88, 87, AT, JT, and have more outs against his 2-pair hands. Smelling weakness, I check-raise all-in for $173 on top of his bet. Now there is $503 in the pot and it costs him $173 to call. I wish my stack were deeper, but this is still a large enough bet to make him pause and think.
He finally makes what looks like crying call and I flip my cards over right away. The river is another 7, putting a pair on the board. He turns over 99, for a flopped set & rivered full house to scoop up the pot. I must have sold him that I was representing QJ there for a turned straight and he felt like he was gambling with the call, whereas in reality all he needed was to fade a Q or 8.
His hand was within the range I assigned to him, but right up near the top of that range. Once again, #theyalwayshaveit. I still think his turn bet was curiously small on such a wet board. Maybe he’s just not a thinking poker player, and that caused a misread on my part. Against his exact hand, my equity was 25.3% on the flop and 18.2% on the turn.
At this point of my day, I’ve been playing about 45 minutes blasted away $500. I take a break for a few minutes, then move to another table where I buy-in for $500 more.
Hand #3 – Donk Bets on Flop Signal Weakness
The villain in this hand is an older (early 70’s?), white haired guy, somewhat the “old man coffee” (“OMC”) type — enjoying his poker game, passing time playing fairly tight and straightforwardly. He started this hand with about $350 in chips and I cover. After he and a couple others limp in, I raise to $20 with QQ. Two others call, then OMC calls.
Flop ($83): J 9 4 rainbow. It checks to OMC, who bets $50. With straightforward players, this “donk bet” (betting into the pre-flop raiser) is usually a good but not great made hand. This looks exactly like he has AJ. With 2-pair or better, he would be more likely to try for a check-raise, with greater confidence that his hand would still be best on the turn if it checks all around. If he does have AJ, I may be able to get his entire stack if I’m patient. Not too quickly, I call, and the others all fold.
Turn ($183): 7c now puts two clubs on the board. OMC bets $25, a strangely small bet, but this doesn’t change my read that I should target him having AJ (despite my misread of a small turn bet in Hand #2, it would be an example of recency bias to change my read here). I raise to $125 by tossing out five green chips. I hope this somehow looks bluffy. He tanks, fidgets, squirms, appears to decide to fold and then change his mind. OMC’s as a general rule are stubborn and hate folding top pair / top kicker hands when they’ve been sitting for a long time just to get one. He calls.
River ($333): 4s. This is a great card for me, pairing the bottom card on the board. If somehow he had donk bet with top two pair (J9) he’s now counterfeited. He checks, I slide out $200 to be sure I cover his remaining ~ $150 or so. He says “you’re going to put me all in aren’t you?” And calls with an expression on his face that says “I know I’m beat, but I’ve gone too far in this hand to give up now.” Without waiting for me to show first, he flips over KJ, confirming my read was almost exactly right. My QQ is good and I drag home a large pot.
In this case, #theyalwayshaveit turned out to be good for me. He had it, but “it” was a hand that I beat and the straightforward nature of his play enabled me to confidently play for stacks with a 1-pair hand.
Hand #4 – Can I Fold KK Pre-Flop?
After the previous hand, OMC left the table and was replaced by another older guy (late 60’s?) who was more of an “old man beer” (“OMB”) than “old man coffee.” He was more social than the first guy, but hadn’t been playing long enough for any other reads prior to this hand. At the start of this hand he has about $250-300 and I have him covered.
After OMB limps in under the gun and the next player folds, I look down at Kh Kd and raise to $17. A woman calls all-in for her last $11 and there is one other call. Then OMB re-raises to $85. WTF?
Wait… did he limp in earlier or was he the big blind? Just to be absolutely sure, I confirm the position of the button on the table as it is in the corner opposite my seat. Then carefully count small blind, then big blind, then OMB. Yes, he definitely limped then re-raised. Dammit! People love to do this with pocket aces.
I ponder Dan Harrington’s seminal books on cash games, where he says no one is good enough to put an opponent on exactly AA and be right often enough to justify folding pocket kings. Since you can re-load anytime in a cash game, his philosophy is to just take your lumps when this happens (unless playing with very deep stacks), so I consider just closing my eyes and shoving all-in.
Then I ponder Occam’s Razor, a problem solving principle that says when there are multiple explanations for an occurrence, the simplest one is usually better. That’s a fancy way of saying #theyalwayshaveit, the simplest explanation for large bets.
And I ponder former poker coach Bill Hubbard, who constantly asked, based on what we know about a villain, “what does he have and how will he play it?” Working backwards, how did he play it (limp / re-raise) and what does that mean he has? #theyalwayshaveit, AA in this case.
And I ponder myself. I have to be a good enough poker player to fold here. But it’s a major ego destroyer. I mean, like, c’mon, this is KKing David’s poker blog. I’m KKing David. I have KK here. This pot is supposed to be mine. After getting beat up in Hands #1 and #2, this is the kind of hand I need to get un-stuck.
This time, I win the battle with my emotions, and reluctantly make the disciplined fold. Since one player is all-in for $11, we get to see the runout. She has 99 and, sure enough, OMB has AA. There are no aces, nor kings, nor nines on the board and OMB scoops up a modest pot.
Deep breathing exercises…
Hand #5 – He Can Only Have Pocket Queens (or Quad Jacks???)
A new player has recently joined the table, two seats to my left. The entire time I’ve been at this table, one of the other guys on this road trip has been on my immediate right. For purposes of this blog, I’ll call him “Zach.” Shortly after the new player arrived, Zach softly commented to me to beware of this new player, who seems to be a very strong and aggressive player, although he is drinking a beer and it’s 3:00 on a Saturday afternoon. I notice his ability to leverage favorable position against passive players.
In this hand, he is the main villain in the cutoff seat, with a stack around $550, which I cover. The button straddles for $6 and three players call. With my first AA of the day, I make it $35. The villain tanks, counting and re-stacking his chips in a manner that tells me he is thinking about re-raising. Zach told me later that it took so long for this guy to act that he was ready to call the clock on him. I just wanted to see him re-raise, but ultimately he calls $35. The button folds, but there are two more out-of-position callers.
Flop ($150): J high and very dry. I don’t recall exactly the two lower cards, other than there was no flush draw nor possible made straight. It is checked to me, and I bet $100. The villain calls almost immediately.
His range for 3-betting pre-flop might be TT+, AQ+ absent any other reads. This is important, as his pondering a 3-bet indicates something in the weaker part of this range or slightly weaker, and also rules out – assuming my read is correct – weaker calling hands. While the player pool here in New Orleans is very loose pre-flop, there hasn’t been much light 3-betting pre-flop, and the straddle and callers in front of me has already push the bet-sizing above normal ranges. He would definitely 3-bet with AA or KK, so that leaves his pre-flop calling range as 88-QQ, AJ+. I heavily discount the TT, 99, 88, AJ part of this range as I don’t think he would take so long to decide to just call my $35 bet.
Now he has confidently called $100 on a J-high flop. There is no T on the board, so he cannot have two over cards with a straight draw (AK, AQ, KQ). We can rule those hands out. He would have to think a bit before calling with TT or any lower pocket pair, so we can rule those out also. I’ve already ruled out AJ based on the pre-flop read, so that leaves QQ and JJ and nothing else. If he flopped a set of Jacks here, it makes sense for him to just call and see if either of the other players wants to come along too, but they both folded. There are six combinations of QQ and three combinations of JJ.
Turn ($350): A low brick arrives that really changes nothing. I check, partly for pot control as my hand is still only one pair and I don’t want to play for stacks yet, and partly to see what he does. He checks back.
River ($350): Another J. Ugh!!!!! I check. At first, I hate this card, as an instinctive reaction to seeing the top card on the board pair. What if he has AJ or KJ – even though I previously ruled these out?
He bets $200. Gulp! I take a deep breath and re-play the hand and re-evaluate my reads based on the action on each street. I have to trust my reads! There are still six combos of QQ that he can have, but now only one combo of JJ. #theyalwayshaveit… in this case “it” is either QQ 85.7% of the time, or JJ 14.3% of the time. It is an unusually precise read. Notice the contrast between this read and Hand #2 above where he could have over 130 combinations. I’m confident that his pre-flop chip handling signaled thoughts about re-raising. Perhaps I should check-raise all-in here, which would really be sick, but that seems very unwise. I call and he shows QQ. Cha-ching!
Zach later pointed out, and I agree, that his river bet there was terrible. The villain was in a “way ahead / way behind” situation. The weakest hand I could would beat him is KK, which will almost never fold there. Most players with a better hand won’t think as much as I did (a flaw? or a gift?) and would just call. And the strongest hand that he beats would be TT, which will almost never call. If you can’t get a better hand to fold nor a weaker hand to call, and you are last to act, just check back and go to showdown. I’m not sure if he thought he was betting for value or if he knew he was turning his QQ into a bluff, or if he even knew why he was betting on that river.
I drag home another large pot, just glad to have turned my day around.